Feb
25
2010
Feb
25
2010
Andrew sings “Sugar we’re going down” by Fall Out Boy
Andrew ended the night on Idol tonight and sang Fall Out Boy’s “Sugar We’re Going Down”
Simon said he was looking forward all night to Andrew singing and he was frankly disappointed in it– it was to serious, to indulgent and not original enough.
Kara thinks he took the risk, but it was a strange risk- she loves that he does take those chances but this one wasn’t right. She did say she really likes him and hopes that we see him again for many many many weeks.
Randy agreed it was strange but he’s a fan of Andrew, he wants him to going back to just being him.
Ellen reminded us how much we loved his rendition of “Straight up” during Hollywood week and that’s the Andrew we want to see. She loved how he opened up when looking over at his wife and that’s what he needs to bring out.